video : a girl disagreeing with me about “transgender” people

2017
 

April Taylor :

I always hear non black women supporting this Ideology! So she doesn鈥檛 exist? Is she saying that gender doesn鈥檛 exist? This is bullshit! Just pure. Bullshit!

M C :

omg x TG doesn’t exist? … u not on the ‘Board’ no more … ‘If you feel more comfortable’ …’ and It makes some ppl uncomfortable’ – who wins? … now tell me why? x <3 LGBT+ and I’m a boring ol’ straighty x ‘pretend’ You patronising a’hole .. fuk biology, acknowledge psychology ffs xx u makin me racist! jk .. if it look like a duck … you still have no fucking idea if it’s a duck….! Omg i was with u ’til now x prick x u are what u feel u r xx u trolling right? 馃槢 an i ate it … 馃檨 dammit think about it .. binary or spectrum … ‘ppl like you are a big part of the problem’.. ffs u narrow minded b’stard .. this girl is right & ty god she stands up for the reality x .. but hey .. u do u …. 馃檨

she is soo LIT <3 ty woke lady x

omg ‘so called’ ffs .. that makes me sick .. u so desperate to assign your ignorance ..

I am a flower … a SunFlower x

T. Rex :

I just found your channel and I must say, I really enjoy the respectful interactions you have with people.

Xyluss Nelms :

Ughhhh. so many atheists are great skeptical, critical thinkers but have such a hard time understanding things like gender vs. sex vs. sexuality. Comparing gender to species is intellectually dishonest.
sex and gender are separate things.

I do really enjoy your epistemological work, though.

Karl :

Gender not as a function of outward appearances but of a brain state and is identifiable and measurable. So therefore is not a matter of choice. Opinion is does not make a difference. If their hypothetical persons have duck DNA and look human they are a duck. Looks are not important.

Christian Fieldhouse :

It’s like the argument “Does a tree that falls in an isolated forest make a sound?”. The definition of “sound” is the only thing you’re debating; you’re not debating what you actually think about reality. Similarly here, you’re just debating the definition of gender: gender could just be defined to be whatever you act like.

littlebit080780 :

Men and women are both people , ducks are not people. It’s not out of the question for a human male to be born with the brain of a human woman , in fact there is science behind it! You are your brain , your brain holds your personhood,, everything that makes you YOU is in your brain , so if your brain is female you are female , at least in the neurological sense, we’ve relabeled this sense as your GENDER ,separate from sex. A human cannot be born with a duck brain. So yes the criteria of gender IS how you FEEL ,b/c it’s to do with your brain ‘s neurological hardwiring, being a duck is determined by different criteria . You are engaged in a straw man fallacy AND a slippery slope fallacy . One thing has nothing to do with the other .

…g :

Marcel – gender, as opposed to sex, appears to be more of a continuum than you seem to be willing to accept.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *